The 2024 NFL season has seen an impressive crop of rookie quarterbacks make their mark on the league. With several first-year signal-callers already leading their teams and showing promise for the future, it’s time to assess their performances and hand out some early grades. Additionally, the recent benching of Giants quarterback Daniel Jones has raised questions about his future in New York and beyond.
Grading the Rookie Quarterbacks
Caleb Williams, Chicago Bears: C+
Despite flashes of brilliance, Williams has struggled with consistency in his first season with the Bears. While his arm talent is undeniable, the rookie has been prone to taking sacks and making ill-advised decisions under pressure. However, much of his struggles can be attributed to a lackluster supporting cast and a midseason coaching change. With better talent around him and more stability, Williams has the potential to develop into a franchise quarterback.
Jayden Daniels, Washington Commanders: A
Daniels has been a revelation for the Commanders, showcasing poise and playmaking ability beyond his years. His elusiveness and accuracy have been key to Washington’s success, and he’s shown an ability to make throws in tight windows. Despite a recent dip in production, likely due to a lingering rib injury, Daniels has been one of the most impressive rookies this season and appears to be a star in the making.
Drake Maye, New England Patriots: A-
Maye has been a godsend for the Patriots, providing stability and accuracy to an offense in desperate need of both. His quick release and decision-making have helped mitigate the team’s offensive line issues, and he’s shown a knack for extending plays with his legs. While he’s still prone to the occasional rookie mistake, Maye’s overall performance has been outstanding, and he appears to be the long-term answer in New England.
Bo Nix, Denver Broncos: B-
After a rocky start to the season, Nix has shown marked improvement in recent weeks. His accuracy and decision-making have been better, and he’s benefited from a more tailored offensive approach. However, much of his statistical output has come in blowout game states, and he still has room for growth in terms of consistency. Nix has the tools to be a successful NFL quarterback, but he’ll need to continue refining his game to reach his potential.
Daniel Jones’ Future
The Giants’ decision to bench Daniel Jones in favor of Tommy DeVito speaks volumes about their plans for the future. With Jones’ contract structured in a way that makes him cuttable after this season, it appears his tenure in New York is coming to an end. However, this may not be the end of the road for the young quarterback.
At just 28 years old next season, Jones still has plenty of football ahead of him. His mobility and toughness could make him an attractive option for teams in need of a bridge starter or competition for a young quarterback. While his time with the Giants has been marred by inconsistency and a lack of talent around him, a change of scenery could do wonders for his career.
Potential landing spots for Jones include the Jets, Steelers, Titans, and Browns. Each of these teams could benefit from a veteran presence like Jones, who has shown flashes of brilliance despite his struggles. With the right supporting cast and coaching staff, he could still develop into a reliable starter in the league.
As the 2024 NFL season continues, all eyes will be on these rookie quarterbacks and their development. While some have already shown star potential, others still have much to prove. Meanwhile, Daniel Jones’ journey is far from over, and his next chapter could be just the fresh start he needs to reach his potential in the NFL.
