The 2024 NFL season has been a showcase of exceptional talent, with players across all positions leaving their mark on the gridiron. As the regular season draws to a close, the debate intensifies over who truly deserves recognition as the league’s elite. In this comprehensive analysis, we delve into the performances, stats, and intangibles to determine our 50-player All-Pro roster for the 2024 campaign.
The Quarterback Conundrum
No position sparks more debate than quarterback, and the 2024 season has been no exception. Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson have been neck-and-neck in the race for the top spot. Allen’s consistency and otherworldly plays have been matched by Jackson’s electrifying performances and clutch moments. While both are deserving, we give the slightest of edges to Allen for his overall body of work.
The Saquon Barkley Show
At running back, Saquon Barkley has been in a league of his own. His vision, elusiveness, and game-breaking ability have elevated the Eagles’ offense to new heights. Barkley’s impact goes beyond just the stat sheet, as his mere presence opens up opportunities for his teammates. It’s hard to imagine a more dominant season from a running back in recent memory.
“Barkley is the most dynamic weapon in the NFL right now. He can single-handedly take over a game.”
– Anonymous NFL Coach
The Receiving Trio
Selecting just three wide receivers for the All-Pro team was an arduous task, but Ja’Marr Chase, Justin Jefferson, and Amon-Ra St. Brown have separated themselves from the pack. Chase’s explosive playmaking, Jefferson’s unparalleled route-running, and St. Brown’s reliability in clutch situations make them the cream of the crop.
- Chase: On pace for the receiving triple crown
- Jefferson: Makes the impossible look routine
- St. Brown: Mr. Dependable on third downs
The Unsung Heroes
While skill positions often steal the spotlight, the true backbone of any successful team lies in the trenches. Tristan Wirfs and Penei Sewell have been the stalwarts at offensive tackle, while Joe Thuney and Quenton Nelson have been the gold standard at guard. Creed Humphrey’s meteoric rise at center rounds out an offensive line that would strike fear into any defensive coordinator.
Defensive Dominance
On the other side of the ball, the All-Pro roster is brimming with game-wreckers. The edge rusher spot is overflowing with talent, but Trey Hendrickson and Myles Garrett have been a cut above the rest. Their relentless pursuit of quarterbacks has been the stuff of nightmares for opposing offenses.
At defensive tackle, Zach Allen and Cameron Heyward have been immovable forces, disrupting both the run and pass with equal effectiveness. Their veteran savvy and technical prowess have been on full display throughout the season.
“Heyward is ageless. He’s still dominating like he did five years ago, if not more.”
– Former All-Pro Defensive Tackle
Linebacker is another position stacked with deserving candidates, but Zack Baun and Frankie Luvu have been the cream of the crop. Baun’s coverage skills have been unmatched, while Luvu’s versatility and playmaking have been vital to the Commanders’ success.
The Shutdown Corners
In a pass-happy league, having elite cornerbacks is a must. Pat Surtain, Derek Stingley Jr., and Christian Gonzalez have been the epitome of shutdown corners. Quarterbacks have learned the hard way that testing these three is a foolish endeavor.
| Cornerback | Passer Rating Allowed |
| Pat Surtain | 55.6 |
| Derek Stingley Jr. | 51.2 |
| Christian Gonzalez | 71.5 |
The Final Pieces
Rounding out the All-Pro roster are the specialist positions. Xavier McKinney and Derwin James have been the league’s best safeties, patrolling the backend with unrivaled range and instincts. Chris Boswell has been automatic as a kicker, while Logan Cooke has flipped the field with his booming punts. KaVontae Turpin has been electric as a returner, consistently providing great field position for his team.
A Season to Remember
The 2024 NFL season has been a showcase of the immense talent that exists across the league. While only 50 players can make the All-Pro roster, there were countless others who had stellar campaigns. As we reflect on the season that was, it’s clear that the future of the NFL is in good hands with the level of play we witnessed this year.
As the playoffs loom, these All-Pro players will look to cement their legacies with postseason success. Regardless of how the season ends, one thing is certain: the 2024 All-Pro roster is a testament to the skill, dedication, and sheer brilliance of the NFL’s elite.
