The Dallas Cowboys’ defense has experienced a surprisingly difficult transition under new defensive coordinator Mike Zimmer, a stark contrast to their previous success with Dan Quinn at the helm. As the team prepares to face their former coordinator, now head coach of the Washington Commanders, the differences in defensive performance are becoming increasingly apparent.
Struggling Defense Under Zimmer
In Zimmer’s first season as defensive coordinator, the Cowboys have seen a significant decline in several key defensive metrics compared to any point during Quinn’s three-year tenure. The team currently ranks worse in yards per game (365.7), points per game (29.3), rushing yards per game (151.0), takeaways (9), third-down percentage (35.2%), and red zone percentage (74.3%) than they ever did under Quinn.
However, there are some areas where the Cowboys’ defense has remained consistent or even improved. The team is allowing fewer passing yards per game (214.7) compared to Quinn’s first season (251.9), and they have maintained the same number of sacks (24) through the first 10 games. Additionally, the defense has given up fewer pass plays of 20 yards or more (31) than they did in 2021 under Quinn (39).
Impact of Injuries
One significant factor contributing to the Cowboys’ defensive struggles has been the numerous injuries to key players. Stars like Micah Parsons, DeMarcus Lawrence, and DaRon Bland have missed significant time, forcing the team to rely on backups and adjust their schemes. In total, defensive players have missed 40 games due to injury so far this season.
I do think when you’re down to your fifth, sixth, seventh, eighth defensive linemen, and you’re down to your fourth, fifth, whatever corner situation, I think that’s going to make a difference.
Mike Zimmer, Dallas Cowboys Defensive Coordinator
In contrast, the Cowboys’ defense remained relatively healthy during Quinn’s tenure, with fewer key players missing extended time. This allowed for greater consistency and continuity in scheme and personnel.
Adjusting Schemes and Personnel
To combat the challenges posed by injuries, Zimmer has had to adjust his defensive plans, altering fronts, personnel packages, and increasing blitz frequency. While these changes have shown some promise, there have been instances of missed opportunities, such as defenders failing to convert free runs at the quarterback into sacks.
As key players like Parsons, Bland, and Lawrence begin to return from injury, the Cowboys are hopeful that their defense will start to resemble the unit that excelled under Quinn. However, some players believe that the issues run deeper than just scheme and personnel.
We’re having the same problems that we had when [Quinn] was here, so, I mean, who’s to blame? You know? It’s always a point finger thing, but at the same time, we got to point the fingers back at ourselves when we don’t perform like that.
Jourdan Lewis, Dallas Cowboys Cornerback
Looking Ahead
As the Cowboys prepare to face their former defensive coordinator, they will need to find a way to recapture the success they enjoyed under his leadership. While the transition to Zimmer’s scheme has been challenging, the return of key players and continued adjustments could help the defense turn the corner.
Ultimately, the Cowboys will need to prove that their defensive struggles are a temporary setback rather than a sign of deeper issues. With a crucial matchup against the Commanders looming, the team has an opportunity to showcase their resilience and prove that they can overcome adversity to become the dominant defensive force they once were.
