The MLB hot stove is sizzling this offseason, with numerous star free agents on the market. But no player is generating more buzz than New York Mets first baseman Pete Alonso. The two-time All-Star and former Home Run Derby champion is one of the game’s premier sluggers and run producers. His future is the subject of endless speculation and debate as teams jockey for position to land the prized free agent.
Alonso’s Historic Production
Since his electric rookie season in 2019, Alonso has established himself as one of MLB’s most feared hitters. The numbers speak for themselves:
- 185 home runs (most in MLB) from 2019-2024
- 571 RBIs (most in MLB) in that span
- Four All-Star selections
- Two Home Run Derby titles
- Never missed more than 7 games in a season
Alonso brings unmatched power and consistency to the heart of any lineup. He’s the caliber of franchise player that can transform an offense. Teams across MLB are envisioning the damage Alonso could do in the middle of their order for years to come.
Projecting Alonso’s Next Contract
So what kind of payday can Alonso expect in free agency? That’s the multimillion-dollar question. Having already turned down a reported 7-year, $158 million extension offer from the Mets, Alonso is aiming high. According to sources, Alonso and agent Scott Boras are seeking a contract in excess of $200 million.
History provides some guidelines for elite first basemen in free agency. The most relevant recent deal is Paul Goldschmidt’s 5-year, $142 million contract with the Cardinals in 2022. Goldschmidt was also 30 years old at the time, but was coming off two stronger seasons than Alonso in 2024.
| First Baseman | Years | Total Value |
| Paul Goldschmidt | 5 | $142M |
| Freddie Freeman | 6 | $158M |
| Chris Davis | 7 | $161M |
Pete is one of the game’s transcendent talents and most marketable stars. He has earned the right to be compensated among the very best at his position. We are engaged in active discussions with multiple clubs who recognize Pete’s rare abilities and intangibles.
– Scott Boras, Pete Alonso’s agent
Given his age and recent performance, a contract in the range of 5 years and $160-180 million seems realistic for Alonso. Though down from initial expectations, that would still rank among the largest deals ever for a first baseman. It’s a fair valuation for a player of his immense ability and importance.
Best Fits for Alonso
While a return to the Mets remains Alonso’s most likely outcome, he will have plenty of suitors on the open market. These teams seem like the best on-field and financial fits:
- Yankees – Desperate for power upgrade, big spenders
- Astros – Contending team with 1B need, room on payroll
- Giants – Looking to make offseason splash, spacious home park
- Mariners – Need middle-of-order bat, ownership willing to spend
The Mets still look like the frontrunners to retain their homegrown star. New York has been Alonso’s home his entire career, and he has become arguably the most popular figure on a franchise flush with cash. It’s hard to imagine the Mets letting him walk away.
But until the ink dries on a new deal, anything is possible. Alonso’s combination of prodigious power, durability, and big-market acclaim makes him a hot commodity that any team would love to build around. A bitter bidding war could be brewing to secure the slugger’s services for the foreseeable future.
One thing is for certain – wherever Alonso plays in 2025 and beyond, that team will be adding a transformational force in the heart of their lineup. Few players in MLB can match Alonso’s capacity for mashing home runs, driving in teammates, and captivating fans. He remains in the prime of a potential Hall of Fame career. How much is that worth? The whole baseball world is watching to find out.
