The inaugural CHL-USA Prospects Challenge wrapped up this week, providing a tantalizing glimpse into the future of hockey. This showcase event featured many of the sport’s brightest young stars, with several players solidifying their status as top prospects for the 2025 NHL Draft. So who were the standouts that made the biggest impact?
Matthew Schaefer Dazzles on Defense
The talk of the town was undoubtedly Matthew Schaefer, the dynamic defenseman who dominated in the CHL’s 6-1 victory in Game 1. His end-to-end rushes, shot-blocking prowess, and ability to control the pace of play had scouts raving. Some even suggest Schaefer could challenge for the first overall pick in 2025.
If he were a right-handed shot, he’d likely be the clubhouse leader for the top pick in June.
– Anonymous NHL Scout
Schaefer’s excellent skating, hockey sense, and two-way impact make him the clear-cut top defensive prospect in this draft class. His performance at the CHL-USA Prospects Challenge only strengthened that assessment.
CHL’s Dynamite Top Line
While Schaefer stole the show on the back end, the CHL’s top forward line of Porter Martone, Michael Misa, and Caleb Desnoyers was equally impressive. This trio dominated shifts with their speed, skill, and tenacity, looking every bit like future top-10 draft picks.
Martone and Misa were the primary play-drivers, using their vision and puck skills to create chances off the rush and in the offensive zone. Desnoyers perfectly complemented their games, demonstrating high hockey IQ, competitiveness, and a knack for being in the right place at the right time.
In what was likely the first live viewing for many NHL general managers, this line made a compelling case to be at the very top of 2025 draft boards. Their chemistry and ability to take over games were on full display.
Other Risers and Surprises
Beyond the marquee names, a few other prospects boosted their draft stock with strong showings:
- Kashawn Aitcheson – The tough, physical defenseman impressed with his devastating point shot and ability to shut down opposing forwards. He projects as a potential top-20 pick.
- Jack Murtagh – The speedy winger accounted for most of Team USA’s offensive chances and scored two of their three goals in the series. He’s trending towards being a first-round selection.
- Harrison Boettiger – The 2026-eligible netminder was outstanding in a losing effort in Game 2, keeping the score respectable with numerous highlight-reel saves. He’ll be on the radar for next year’s draft.
A Springboard for Draft Season
While it’s important not to put too much stock into a two-game sample, the CHL-USA Prospects Challenge serves as a critical early showcase with NHL GMs and scouts in attendance. The players who shone the brightest have set themselves up for increased attention and scrutiny as the 2024-25 season unfolds.
For the likes of Schaefer, Martone, and Misa, their lofty draft projections appear well-founded based on their play this week. Meanwhile, the emergence of prospects like Aitcheson, Murtagh, and Boettiger has added intriguing wrinkles to the 2025 draft landscape. As the road to the NHL Draft continues, these are the names that will be front and center in the discussion of hockey’s future stars.
